All-time Team and Individual Records

Men’s team records

Most goals scored, game: 10 (once. Last: July 13, 2024 vs. Dayton Dutch Lions)

Least goals scored, game: 0 (30 times. Last: May 29, 2024 at Toledo Villa)

Most goals allowed, game: 5 (five times. Last: June 1, 2024 at Cleveland Force)

Least goals allowed, game: 0 (41 times. Last: July 13, 2024 vs. Dayton Dutch Lions)

Women’s team records

Most goals scored, game: 11 (June 21, 2023 vs FC Berlin)

Least goals scored, game: 0 (four times. Last: July 19, 2024 vs Santa Clarita Blue Heat)

Most goals allowed, game: 5 (June 20, 2021 at Scorpions SC)

Least goals allowed, game: 0 (13 times. Last: June 29, 2024 at vs FC Berlin)

Women’s player records (sortable)

ALL-TIME GOALS

1. Carissima Cutrona (28)

2. Marcy Barberic (20)

3. Kelsey Araujo (10)

4. Morgan Kulniszewski (8)

5. Ella Rudney (7)

ALL-TIME ASSISTS

1. Carissima Cutrona (23)

2. Sarah Woods (14)

3. (tie) Marcy Barberic and Kelsey Araujo(8)

5. Morgan Kulniszewski (7)

ALL-TIME APPEARANCES

1. Carissima Cutrona (45)

2. Erin Weir (39)

3. Tess Ford (39)

4. Dani Vis (30)

5. Emily Lazenby (26)

Men’s player records (sortable)

ALL-TIME GOALS

1. Ander Castillo (26)

2. Kendell McFayden (18)

3. Akean Shackleford (15)

4. (tie) Mike Unwin, Andy Tiedt (10)

ALL-TIME ASSISTS

1. Chris Walter (9)

2. Andy Tiedt (7)

3. (tie) Mike Unwin, Russell Cicerone, Brian Knapp (6)

ALL-TIME APPEARANCES

1. Chris Walter (88)

2. (tie) Kendell McFayden (45), Robert Williamson (45)

4. Bobby Ross (33)

5. Ander Castillo (32)

CLEAN SHEETS

Bryce Tramuta (7)
Andrew Coughlin (5)
Dan Panaro (4)
Steve Casey (4)
Jeremy Figler (4)
Nick Jeffs (3)
Nick Fetterman (2)
Kareem Gray (2)
Waleed Cassis (2)
Andreas Queen (2)
Patrick Regna (1)
Jordan Dilapo (1)
Craig Yanni (1)
Matt Stedman/Corey Phillips (1)
Eric Dehond (1)
Cameron Hogg (1)
Will Banahene (1)
Andreas Kokoska (1)

WINS
Bryce Tramuta (11)
Andrew Coughlin (8)
Jeremy Figler (7)
Andreas Kokoska (7)
Waleed Cassis (5)
Dan Panaro (4)
Kareem Gray (4)
Steve Casey (4
Craig Yanni (3)
Nick Jeffs (3)
Cameron Hogg (3)
Andreas Queen (3)
Will Banahene (2)
Nick Fetterman (1)
Patrick Regna (1)
Jordan Dilapo (1)
Brian Wagstaff (1)
Matt Stedman/Corey Phillips (1)
Jamie Barry (1)
Jack Petrie (1)

DRAWS

Cameron Hogg (3)
Jeremy Figler (3)
Andreas Kokoska (3)
Steve Casey (2)
Bryce Tramuta (2)
Nick Fetterman (2)
Eric Dehond (2)
Arthur Hill (2)
Nick Jeffs (1)
Jordan Dilapo (1)
Kareem Gray (1)
Andrew Coughlin (1)

Men’s 10th Anniversary Team

Men’s most goals in one game (individual)

• Rich Wilson (3)  (July 3, 2010 vs. TSC Maryland Red Devils)
• Akean Shackleford (3)  (May 27, 2018 vs. Syracuse FC)
• Ander Castillo (3) (June 11, 2024 vs Cleveland Force and July 13, 2024 vs Dayton Dutch Lions)

Men’s most assists in one game (individual):

• t1. Nevado Elliott (3) (May 31, 2019 vs. Syracuse FC)
• Jayson Repine (3) (July 28, 2021 vs. Cleveland SC)
• 2. Done 12 times by 11 players

• Mike Unwin(2) (July 11, 2010 vs. FC Reading Revolution)
• Krystian Witkowski(2) (July 16, 2011 vs. Buxmont Torch)
• Andy Tiedt(2) (July 16, 2011 vs. Buxmont Torch)
• Josh Faga(2) (July 17, 2011 vs. New Jersey Blaze)
• Brian Knapp (2) (May 17, 2013 vs. FC Sparta Michigan)
• Russell Cicerone (2) (July 13, 2014 vs. Michigan Stars)
• Ian Mort (2) (May 16, 2014 at Erie Admirals)
• Erik Dahl (2) (May 29, 2015 at FC Indiana Lions)
• Andrew Ferguson (2) (May 31, 2015 at Indiana Fire)
• Brian Knapp (2) (June 13, 2015 at Michigan Stars)
• Anthony Rozzano (2) (July 3, 2015 at Erie Commodores)
• Philip Persson (2) (June 24, 2016 vs. AFC Cleveland)
• Isaiah Barrett (2) (June 11, 2017 vs. Syracuse FC)
• Isaiah Barrett (2) (June 25, 2017 at Dayton Dynamo)
• Fox Slotemaker (2) (July 9, 2017 at Fort Pitt Regiment)
• Chris Walter (2) (July 7, 2018 at Greater Binghamton FC)
• Rodrigo Almeida (2) (June 4, 2021 v Erie Commodores)

Honors/awards

League honors

2024

Men
Ander Castillo – USL Divisional Player of the Year – Valley Division

Women
UWS Iron Division champions
UWS National semi-finalist
Tess Ford – All-UWS First Team
Brigid Mulholland – All-UWS First Team
Claire DeAngelis – UWS National Championship Best XI
Skylar Cornell – UWS National Championship Best XI
Carissima Cutrona – UWS Team of the Week (Wk2)
Skylar Cornell – UWS Team of the Week (Wk6)
Brigid Mulholland – UWS Team of the Week (Wk6)
Tess Ford – UWS Team of the Week (Wk6)
Claire DeAngelis – UWS Team of the Week (Wk7)

2023

Women
UWS East Division champions
Marcy Barberic – UWS Most Valuable Player
Marcy Barberic – All-UWS First Team
Marcy Barberic – UWS Offensive Player of the Week (3x)
Marcy Barberic – UWS Team of the Week (3x)
Marcy Barberic – UWS East Conference Best XI First Team
Carissima Cutrona – All-UWS Second Team
Carissima Cutrona – UWS East Conference Best XI First Team
Carissima Cutrona – UWS Team of the Week (2x)
Sarah Woods – UWS Offensive Player of the Week
Sarah Woods – UWS East Conference Best XI Second Team
Payton Robertson – UWS Team of the Week
Payton Robertson – UWS East Conference Best XI Second Team
Tess Ford – All-UWS Second Team
Tess Ford – UWS East Conference Best XI First Team
Emma Klein – UWS Team of the Week

Men
Arthur Hill – USL League Two Save of the Week, Week Two

2022

Women
UWS Penn-NY Division champions
UWS East Conference champions
UWS National semi-finalist
Nikki Bartholomew – UWS East Conference Coach of the Year
Carissima Cutrona – UWS Most Valuable Player
Carissima Cutrona – UWS National First Team
Carissima Cutrona – UWS East Conference Best XI First Team
Carissima Cutrona – UWS East Conference Offensive Player of the Year
Tess Ford – UWS East Conference Best XI First Team
Djeynaba “DJ” Thiam – UWS National Second Team
Djeynaba “DJ” Thiam – UWS East Conference Best XI First Team
Emily Kelly – UWS East Conference Best XI Second Team
UWS Live Gameday Experience Team of the Year

Men
Max Kwitchoff – NPSL Rust Belt Conference Best XI

2021

Women
UWS East Division regular season champions
Nikki Bartholomew – UWS East Conference Coach of the Year
Kelsey Araujo – UWS East Conference Best XI First Team
Carissima Cutrona – UWS East Conference Best XI First Team
Marcy Barberic – UWS East Conference Best XI Second Team
Maya Palmer – UWS East Conference Best XI Second Team
Emily Kelly – UWS East Conference Best XI Honorable Mention
Kelsey Araujo – UWS East Conference Offensive Player of the Year
Kelsey Araujo – UWS Offensive Player of the Year
Kelsey Araujo – All-UWS First Team
Carissima Cutrona – All-UWS Second Team
UWS Digitial Gameday Experience Team of the Year
UWS Rookie Team of the Year

Men
Josh Tufino – Football Manager NPSL Team of the Week (7/6)
Christoffer Jensen – Football Manager NPSL Team of the Week (5/26)
Rob Williamson – NPSL Rust Belt Conference Best XI
Habib Famuditimi – NPSL Rust Belt Conference Best XI
Habib Famuditimi – NPSL East Region Best XI
Stefan Copetti – NPSL Rust Belt Conference Best XI

2019
Nevado Elliott – NPSL East Conference Best XI
Kieran Toland – NPSL East Conference Best XI
Nevado Elliott – Top Drawer Soccer NPSL Team of the Week (2x – 6/6, 6/20)
Bryce Tramuta – Top Drawer Soccer NPSL Team of the Week (6/20)

2018
Kendell McFayden – NPSL East Conference Best XI
Euan Bauld – Top Drawer Soccer NPSL Team of the Week (6/17)
Steve Casey – Top Drawer Soccer NPSL Team of the Week (6/3)
Akean Shackleford – Top Drawer Soccer NPSL Team of the Week (5/26)

2017
Akean Shackleford – NPSL Midwest Conference, Best XI
Akean Shackleford – NPSL All-East Division, First XI
Bayley Winkel – NPSL All-East Division, First XI
Fox Slotemaker – NPSL All-East Division, Second XI

2015
Kendell McFayden – NPSL Best XI
Kendell McFayden – NPSL Player of the Week
Andrew Ferguson – NPSL All-Midwest Conference, First XI
Fox Slotemaker – NPSL All-Midwest Conference, First XI
Andrew Coughlin – NPSL All-Midwest Conference, Honorable Mention
Andrew Coughlin – NPSL Supporters’ XI, Second Team
Adam Lauko – NPSL All-Midwest Conference, Honorable Mention
Matthew Ferguson – NPSL Supporters’ XI, First Team

2014
Russell Cicerone – NPSL Best XI
Russell Cicerone – NPSL Player of the Week

2011
Corey Phillips – NPSL All-Star Team

2010
Daniel Stevens – NPSL All-Star Team captain
Dan Panaro – NPSL All-Star Team

Team honors

Near the conclusion of each regular season, FC Buffalo conducts a survey of our players to determine some individual honors.

Best Offensive Player

2024 winners: Ander Castillo (men); Carissima Cutrona (women)
2023 winners: Calum Newson (men); Marcy Barberic (women)
2022 winners: Ander Castillo and Jordan Araujo (men); Carissima Cutrona (women)
2021 winners: Stefan Copetti (men); Kelsey Araujo (women)
2020 winner: Nuukele Gboe
2019 winner: Kieran Toland
2018 winner: Keane McIvor
2017 winner: Akean Shackleford
2016 winner: (tie) Romario Guscott and Kieran Toland
2015 winner: Brett Larocque
2014 winner: Russell Cicerone
2013 winner: Ian Mort
2012 winner: Mike Reidy
2011 winner: Mike Reidy
2010 winner: Richie Wilson

Best Defensive Player

2024 winners: Fabian Overkamp and Landon Hungerford (men); Tess Ford and Claire DeAngelis (women)
2023 winners: Riley Wagner (men); Tess Ford (women)
2022 winners: Zach Drayer (men); Tess Ford (women)
2021 winners: Robert Williamson (men); Emily Kelly and Maya Palmer (women)
2020 winner: Robert Williamson
2019 winner: Josh Read
2018 winner: Euan Bauld
2017 winner: Jordan Sinclair
2016 winner: David Acuna Camacho
2015 winner: Andrew Coughlin
2014 winner: Jake Rinow
2013 winner: Bobby Ross
2012 winner: Josh Hall
2011 winner: Corey Phillips
2010 winner: Mbwana Johnson

Unsung Hero

2024 winners: Ollie Lovell (men); Dani Martinez and Kasia Bak (women)
2023 winners: Derek Bartlo (men); Danielle Vis (women)
2022 winners: Max Kwitchoff and Zach Drayer (men); Emily Kelly and Payton Robertson (women)
2021 winners: Zach Drayer and Josh Tufino (men); Danielle Vis (women)
2020 winner: Jordan Acevedo
2019 winner: Austin Stout
2018 winner: Austin Stout
2017 winner: Jake Cooper
2016 winner: Jack Donaldson
2015 winner: (tie) Connor Willings, Fox Slotemaker and Brett Larocque
2014 winner: Marcus Hanson
2013 winner: (tie) Brian Knapp and Bobby Ross
2012 winner: Patrick Zelko
2011 winners: (tie) Andrew Larracuente and Joshua Faga
2010 winner: John Grabowski

Most Valuable Player

2024 winners: Ander Castillo (men); Carissima Cutrona and Tess Ford (women)
2023 winners: Ander Castillo (men); Payton Robertson (women)
2022 winners: Max Kwitchoff (men); Carissima Cutrona (women)
2021 winners: Chris Jensen (men); Kelsey Araujo and Carissima Cutrona (women)
2020 winner: Zach Drayer
2019 winner: Kieran Toland
2018 winner: Euan Bauld
2017 winner: Fox Slotemaker
2016 winner: (tie) Jack Donaldson and Johnny McBeth
2015 winner: Andrew Ferguson
2014 winner: Russell Cicerone
2013 winner: Ian Mort
2012 winners: (tie) Mike Reidy and Andy Tiedt
2011 winner: Joshua Faga
2010 winner: Daniel Stevens

Heart and Soul Award

2024 winners: Max Kwitchoff (men); Dani Vis (women)
2023 winners: Derek Bartlo (men); Carissima Cutrona (women)
2022 winners: Bryce Tramuta and Derek Bartlo (men); Carissima Cutrona and Danielle Vis (women)
2021 winners: Chris Walter (men); Carissima Cutrona and Bizzy Moore (women)
2020 winner: Ali Shawish
2019 winner: Kieran Toland
2018 winner: Kendell McFayden
2017 winner: Chris Walter